Why does health advice change?

A local athlete asks a doctor why the advice on getting COVID and flu shots together changed.

A rough black-and-white doodle of an athlete and a doctor talking across a table.

The conversation

A fictional conversation about a real change in vaccine guidance.

The question The 14-day rule The UK trial Follow-up

Athlete

“I play here in town. I asked an infectious disease doctor from our local clinic to help me answer a question someone sent in: Why should I trust a medical recommendation when recommendations can change?”

Physician

“I’d want to know what changed, too. Let’s look at one example: why public health officials first asked people to space out COVID and flu shots, then dropped that general rule.”

Athlete

“So why were people told to wait between the two shots in the first place?”

Physician

“Early on, the CDC advised spacing COVID-19 vaccines at least 14 days from other shots so it would be easier to track side effects. In May 2021, they dropped that general rule. They had more COVID vaccine safety data and years of experience giving other vaccines together. There still wasn’t much direct evidence on giving a COVID shot with another vaccine.”

See the CDC meeting notes

Athlete

“Did anyone actually compare the same-day visit with spacing them out?”

Physician

“Yes. Later in 2021, a UK trial randomly assigned 679 adults to get a flu shot on the same day as their second COVID shot or three weeks later. For the combinations tested, researchers found no new safety concerns and antibody responses held up. That study covered particular vaccines and second doses. Later boosters were outside its scope.”

Physician

“When you hear that advice has changed, ask what led to the change and what’s still uncertain. Those are fair questions.”

See the study and its limits

Athlete

“I’m still wondering about that phrase ‘no new safety concerns.’ What could a trial this size tell us about rare side effects?”

Physician

“That’s a good question for the next conversation. We can look at what a trial can measure and why safety monitoring continues afterward.”

Try leaving a follow-up question

Sources for the episode

CDC advisory meeting · May 2021

Why the CDC changed its advice

The May meeting minutes describe the original 14-day rule and explain why the CDC lifted it while same-day data were still limited.

Read the meeting notes (opens in a new tab)

The Lancet · November 2021

Same visit or separate visits?

The ComFluCOV trial compared the two schedules in 679 adults and measured short-term reactions and antibody responses. It was published after the CDC update.

Read the trial (opens in a new tab)

What would you ask?

Viewers could ask questions anonymously. The athlete could bring one to the doctor in the next episode.

Your draft stays on this page until you reload.

Examples I looked at

Pfizer TV spot · 2023

Travis Kelce, “Two Things at Once”

A pharmacist introduces the idea of getting COVID and flu shots in one visit. The rest of the spot mostly follows Kelce and the joke about doing two things at once.

See the original campaign (opens in a new tab)

I’d keep the joke and have Kelce ask the pharmacist a follow-up. I wanted to hear the answer the pharmacist could give if there were more time.

Instagram Live Q&A · 2020

Steph Curry and Dr. Anthony Fauci

Curry brought questions to Fauci during a live conversation about COVID-19. He gave Fauci time to explain the reasoning behind his answers.

See the Warriors’ recap (opens in a new tab)

Video series · 2021

The Conversation: Between Us, About Us

W. Kamau Bell spoke with Black doctors, nurses and researchers about questions Black communities had about COVID-19 vaccines. Short videos dealt with one question at a time.

Explore the campaign (opens in a new tab)